City of Oakland Sues Federal Government to Prevent Closure of Harborside Health CenterBy Thomas H. Clarke | The Daily Chronic October 12, 2012
In an historic development, the city of Oakland announced it filed a suit in U.S. District Court to enjoin U.S. Attorney Eric Holder and U.S. Attorney Melinda Haag from their attempts to close Harborside Health Center, a fully compliant state and city licensed medical cannabis dispensary.
OAKLAND, CA — The City of Oakland filed a complaint in United States District Court Wednesday seeking to prevent the federal government from seizing an Oakland building used by a medical cannabis dispensary.
The property at 1840 Embarcadero is the location of the Harborside Health Center, a medical cannabis dispensary operating under a permit issued by the City of Oakland. In July, the U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of California filed a forfeiture action against the real property where the dispensary is located. The City’s lawsuit does not seek damages, but asks the court to enjoin and declare unlawful the federal government’s attempt to close down the dispensary.
San Francisco law firm Morrison & Foerster LLP is representing the City in this case and filed the complaint on the City’s behalf.
“The federal government has acted beyond its authority by initiating the forfeiture action outside of the statute of limitations,” Morrison & Foerster partner Cedric Chao said today. “Moreover, the government has indicated for many years by its words and actions that so long as dispensaries and medical patients acted consistently with state law, the dispensaries would be allowed to operate. Oakland has reasonably relied on these assurances, and the government should be prohibited from disrupting Oakland’s medical cannabis program.”
“This lawsuit is about protecting the rights of legitimate medical patients,” City Attorney Barbara Parker said. “I am deeply dismayed that the federal government would seek to deny these rights and deprive thousands of seriously ill Californians of access to safe, affordable and effective medicine.”
Harborside Health Center is a nationally acclaimed model of legitimacy and legal compliance in the medical cannabis industry, and was featured on the Discovery Channel series “Weed Wars.”
“We are heartened and encouraged by the City of Oakland’s lawsuit against Attorney General Eric Holder and US Attorney Melinda Haag, and welcome the City’s support,” Steve DeAngelo, Executive Director of Harborside Health Center, said in a statement.
“Ms. Haag has attacked not only Harborside and our patients, but also the entire system of regulated medical cannabis distribution painstakingly developed by the City. Those regulations were developed in response to very real and serious problems caused by unregulated sales of medical cannabis, and have improved public safety while raising substantial tax revenue. If Ms. Haag is successful in her efforts, our 112,000 patients will be forced to the illicit marketplace, over $25 million in annual cannabis sales will move back to the streets of Oakland, the City will lose its second largest retail tax payer, and our more than 100 employees will no longer have jobs.
“It is shameful that Ms. Haag and her colleagues, who are sworn to protect public safety, have chosen to spend limited law enforcement resources closing down licensed and regulated dispensaries, instead of targeting meth labs or human trafficking. The President should immediately freeze all enforcement actions against medical cannabis providers, and review them to make sure they are consistent with administration policy to target only those providers who are out of compliance with state law.”
The City of Oakland carefully created a regulatory scheme for medical cannabis dispensaries in order to maintain public health and safety, including the issuance of permits, the monitoring of licensed dispensaries, annual auditing of the dispensaries’ financial statements, and employee background checks to ensure compliance with state and city law.
The benefits of medical cannabis to patients suffering from chronic pain associated with debilitating illnesses such as cancer, AIDS, and multiple sclerosis are well documented.
“Well-regulated dispensaries provide affordable medical cannabis in a controlled, secure setting, which decreases the market for illegal marijuana,” Chao said. “Closing dispensaries will not reduce the demand for medical cannabis, but instead will create a distribution vacuum that will drive suffering medical patients into the arms of street dealers, thereby putting the patients’ health and safety at risk.”
Parker added: “As Oakland’s City Attorney, I strongly oppose federal actions against Oakland businesses that are complying with state and local laws and paying their fair share of taxes. My hope is that the federal government will focus its resources on the real crisis in Oakland – violent crime and illegal guns that are snuffing out so many lives. In the midst of this crisis, it is a tragic waste for the federal government to spend its time and resources cracking down on legitimate health care providers.”
Parker and Chao are former Assistant U.S. Attorneys in the Northern District of California.Department of Justice , DOJ , Eric Holder , marijuana dispensary raids , medical marijuana , The War on Marijuana , War on Marijuana